How Moscow Orchestrated Events in Crimea6
Suppose you are torn between dedicating your life to art (say, by becoming a concert pianist) or to helping others (say, by going to medical school and joining Doctors Without Borders). How do you decide? There is no common currency in which artistic creation and moral goodness might be compared; these are but two of a plurality of incommensurable values that can be realized in a human life. Do you then ask yourself which choice will bring you greater future happiness? That’s no good either, for the path you choose will shape the very person you become, along with the preferences you develop; so to base your decision on the satisfaction of those preferences would be circular.
Hall never confronts this deep indeterminacy. Instead, he assures us that even if we can’t say what wisdom is, “we know it when we see it.” In fairness, the researchers he cites haven’t done any better — and their jargon is a lot worse, judging from research-paper titles like “Wisdom: A Metaheuristic (Pragmatic) to Orchestrate Mind and Virtue Toward Excellence.”
orchestrate
Syllabification: or·ches·trate
Pronunciation: /ˈôrkiˌstrāt
/
沒有留言:
張貼留言